Alrashim Chambers, 25, was charged in the slaying of Victoria Carmen White, who had undergone sexual reassignment surgery
MAPLEWOOD — Victoria Carmen White’s death was about ego, anger and an illegal gun, an Essex County assistant prosecutor told the jury in Newark Tuesday.
Her accused killer, Alrashim Chambers, stands charged with murder, bias intimidation and weapons offenses in the fatal shooting of the 28-year-old transgender female, whom he had met hours earlier at an Irvington nightclub.
"But for Carmen White’s status as a transgender individual, I would submit to you she would be alive today," Assistant Prosecutor Eileen O’Connor said during her opening statements in Superior Court.
What began that night as "a festive event of young people, turned very violent, very very quickly," O’Connor said. White, a lingerie model whom everyone called Carmen, was found dead of multiple gunshot wounds inside her cousin’s Maplewood apartment on Sept. 12, 2010, a few blocks from the nightclub.
Born a male, she had undergone sexual reassignment surgery after high school and had legally changed her name. O’Connor called the killing "a gross overreaction" on Chambers’ part, "when he realized this individual wasn’t a woman, or at some point had been a man."
His alleged accomplice, Marquise Foster, was also charged with murder, but has since pleaded guilty to a lesser offense in exchange for his testimony against the defendant, expected later this week.
Chambers, 25, sat quietly at the defense table Tuesday as his attorney acknowledged he was in the apartment that night. However, the attorney, Bukie Adetula, accused Foster of the killing, noting his extensive criminal record.
"He is an experienced crook," Adetula said of Foster, 26, who last year pleaded guilty to an unrelated gun possession charge. "He knows the buttons to push, when to reach out to the prosecutor’s office, how to tell a story."
Adetula maintained his client’s innocence and did not address the bias charge in court. But in an interview afterward, he said "there is no basis for it. Even in the best of circumstances, it just isn’t there. You can be shocked, and react. But how is it done with an eye toward intimidating?"
John O'Boyle/The Star-LedgerAlrashim Chambers of Newark is arraigned in connection with the fatal shooting of Victoria Carmen White at the Essex County courthouse in Newark in this 2010 photo.
Tuesday, two women who were also in the Maplewood apartment the night of the killing and who testified for the prosecution appeared to point the finger at Chambers. Both claimed they saw him and White kissing in the studio apartment that evening. Foster, meanwhile, was on the phone and wasn’t mingling with White, they said.
The women, Sharon White — the victim’s cousin — and Natasha Wray, said they went into the bathroom to give the couple some privacy. "They were hugging on each other," Sharon White said on direct examination.
When the bathroom door briefly swung open at one point, the women saw White leaning against Chambers, with her shirt partially pulled up. "I yelled to my cousin, was she good," Sharon White testified. "She said she was ok."
Minutes later, the party turned deadly.
Sharon White and Wray said they heard a man yell: "You a dude?" followed by three gunshots.
The bathroom door was closed at that point so neither could tell who fired the shots. They also couldn’t tell who uttered the statement, the tone of which sounded like "a question, with anger," as Sharon White put it.
In his previous statement to police, Foster said he and Chambers both had sexual encounters with Carmen White during those few minutes when the women were in the bathroom, but that only the defendant suspected she was a transgender female.
The trial continues today, with Chambers’ cousin expected to take the stand for the prosecution. She provided testimony at a grand jury hearing but O’Connor indicated to the judge Tuesday that her statement may have since changed.
Related coverage:
• Man pleads not guilty to fatal shooting of transgender lingerie model in Maplewood
• Newark man indicted on murder and intimidation of transgender woman
• Three accused in separate Maplewood slayings plead not guilty
• Second man accused of fatally shooting Maplewood transgender model surrenders